Quality Crafted Cookie Cutters & Decorating Ideas

nerdy cupcake cookies

Decorated Cookies

How to Make Nerdy Cupcake Cookies

Written by Mike Tamplin Jun 30, 2017


How to make nerdy cupcake cookies by www.SemiSweetDesigns.com

Hi, I’m Mike and I’m a procrastinator. (“Hi, Mike.”)

I truly intended for these nerdy cupcake cookies to be ready for Teacher Appreciation week last month. But as Life tends to happen, I couldn’t find the time to fit it in. Also, it didn’t help that the rising summer temps made me less motivated to turn on the oven.

I may have missed the bus for Teacher Appreciation week, but these nerdy cupcake cookies could also work for Back-to-School in a month’s time. You could consider this an early idea for the upcoming occasion. Plus, the nerdy glasses look is always in style. (At least that’s what I tell myself.)

Cupcake and Plaque Cookie Cutters

Added to the shop are two new designs: a cupcake cookie cutter and a new icon plaque cookie cutter.

cupcake and icon plaque cookie cutters

Cupcake Cookie Cutter

This cupcake cookie cutter was designed to be cute. The whipped topping was shaped in a way for adding a whimsical face while sporting a dollop hairdo. The cupcake cutter used for this tutorial is a REGULAR size.

Icon Plaque Cookie Cutter

This icon plaque cookie cutter is perfect for adding a little flair to a message cookie. The top “crown” area provides enough space to add an icon image or decoration, while the remaining sides are have an elegant style to them.

Template for the Nerdy Cupcake Cookies

To help with the decorating process, I made a PDF template available for the cookie designs shown. Included in the file are templates for a nerdy girl and a nerdy boy cupcake. For the boy cupcake version, I made things a little different by flipping the cookie cutout over before baking. This makes his “hair” face the opposite way as the girl’s to add some variety.

You can download the nerdy cupcake cookie templates HERE.

If you have a Kopykake or Pico projector, just print it out (or pull it up on your mobile device) and you are good to go. For those without a projector, follow the suggested steps below by tracing the design onto the cookie with an edible food marker.

The Decorating Process

For this tutorial, I’ll be decorating the girl version of the cupcake. However, the boy version is practically identical and the same steps below would still apply.

To make these nerdy cupcake cookies, you will need the following suggested colors:

  1. For those without a projector, begin by making a guideline for where the center cupcake band should be. I made a template with template plastic from the PDF file above and used a food marker to draw the guideline on the cookie.

    nerdy cupcake cookies step 1
  2. Begin by outlining and filling the middle cupcake band with tan icing. Then quickly add a few accent dots with the darker tan flood icing. Let this icing set for about 15 minutes.

    Next, outline and fill the top area with pink icing. Do the same for the bottom area with teal icing. (Note: With there being so many color options for cupcakes, feel free you choose any other colors as you wish.)

    Let the icing dry completely before moving on (about 2 hours).

    nerdy cupcake cookies step 2
  3. Once the base layer had time to dry, add a cherry with red icing. Also, outline and add lines to the cupcake liner for more dimension.

    Lastly, add the finishing touches by outlining the pink frosting, adding the cherry stem, and adding the face.

    nerdy cupcake cookies step 3

Video Tutorial

The steps above are summarized in this time-lapsed video below.

The shape of these nerdy cupcake cookies is pretty universal, making it easy to change it from a girl to a boy. Just switching out the eyeglass frames and the adding/removing eyelashes transforms the cupcake to a totally different person.

I could also possibly see these cupcakes decorated as Halloween monsters, like a vampire or a mummy, when the time comes later in the year.

nerdy cupcake cookies

To accompany the nerdy cupcake cookies, I added a new plaque cutter design: the icon plaque. I placed a tiny cupcake icon to tie the two cookie designs together.

It’s a fun way of adding an end-of-school-year or start-of-summer message as a thank you gift for your kid’s favorite teacher.

nerdy cupcake cookies boy

Or, it could be used as a sweet message of optimism for the upcoming school year.

nerdy cupcake cookies girl

These two cookies fit great in these 7″x 4.5″x 1.25″ Simplex cookie box made by BRP Box Shop, making it the perfect presentation for the gift set.

I hope everyone is enjoying their summer!


Filed under:

7 replies on “How to Make Nerdy Cupcake Cookies

  1. Love this cutter and the decorating options! Can’t wait to get mine in the mail 😊 The template is linking back to the whale set…. thanks for continuing to come up with awesome designs that we can realistically decorate….I definitely stalk your blog and IG posts… lol

    1. Thanks for letting me know, DeAnna! I updated the template link. :) Also, your kind comments are so appreciative! Thank you!!

      1. Thanks, that was quick 😊 You’re welcome, just a super fan of your work and a bit of a stalker for your new cutters but I’m harmless lol 🙄

  2. Ah. those letters. Will you be showing us how to do those, please? :).

    1. Hi Judit, there’s not much to it. I just use a projector and trace. For thin letters, use piping consistency icing. For the thicker fonts, use slightly thinner than piping consistency.

  3. Super cute. I love your tutorials :-)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subcribe to the Newsletter

Get promotions, new products and blog updates delivered to your inbox.