Quality Crafted Cookie Cutters & Decorating Ideas

How to Make Cupid Cookies by SemiSweetDesigns.com

Decorated Cookies

How to Make Cupid Cookies

Written by Mike Tamplin Jan 23, 2018


How to Make Cupid Cookies by SemiSweetDesigns.com

At the start of the new year, I reached out on Facebook and asked for suggestions for possible Valentine’s Day cookie designs. Thank you so much for your creative ideas and suggestions. I really appreciated the brainstorming help.

Out of all the suggestions, overwhelmingly the most popular request was for cupid cookies.

I was a little hesitant to accommodate that request because “people” cookies tend to be a challenge to decorate. There’s usually a lot of details involved compared to other designs, and any slight mistake (especially in the face) can be unforgiving.

That being said, I was determined to come up with what I call a “simplified cupid design”.

These cupid cookies are still a bit intricate, but I tried to remove some detail work by creating a side profile cupid cookie. This way only one half of the body is showing, taking away half the decorating work. In addition, I created a “simpler” version of a cupid peeking over a heart. This design further eliminates the body details altogether, leaving just the head and wings to decorate.

The tutorial below goes over how to decorate the full-body version of the cupid cookies. However, the steps can be applied to the cupid on a heart version, as well.

Cupid Cookie Cutters

As mentioned above, I have two cupid cookie designs available in the shop.

cupid cookie cutters

I sized the cupid body cookie cutter and the cupid on heart cookie cutter accordingly so they both will fit perfectly inside a single favor 4″x4″ gift box.

Template for the Cupid Cookies

To help with the decorating process, I made a PDF template available for the two cupid cookie designs shown.

You can download the cupid cookie templates HERE.

If you have a Kopykake or Pico projector, just print it out (or pull it up on your mobile device) and you are good to go. For those without a projector, follow the suggested steps below by tracing the design onto the cookie with an edible food marker.

The Decorating Process

For these cupid cookies, you will need the following suggested colors:

  1. For those without a projector, begin by making a guideline for where the head and body sections should be. I made a template with template plastic from the PDF file above and used a food marker to draw the guideline on the cookie.

    cupid cookies step 1
  2. Using the marker line as a guide, outline and then flood alternating sections. I began with the chest and the back leg sections first. I let those sections set up for about 20 minutes, then moved on to the face and booty sections.

    Let these sections dry for about an hour before moving on.

    cupid cookies step 2
  3. Next, fill in the hair, heart, front leg, and wing sections. Let these sections set.

    Once the red icing of the heart had crusted over, add the arm and then the facial details, as shown. Let the whole cookie dry for about 1-2 hours before moving on.

    cupid cookies step 3
  4. Finally, add the outline details around the hair, chin, wings and booty.

    cupid cookies step 4

Video Tutorial

The steps above are summarized in the time-lapsed video below.

Here’s the finished cupid cookies, along with the “simpler” cupid on a heart design.

Cupid Cookies by SemiSweetDesigns.com

As you can see, they will fit nicely in the 4″x4″ gift box from Clear Bags.

Printable Gift Tags and Bag Toppers

Additionally, to enhance the presentation of these cupid cookies, my brother at OwlHouse.Co created a set of beautiful tags and bag toppers to coordinate with the cookie design.

cupid cookie tags
cupid cookie bag toppers

For the bag toppers, there is a 4-inch and a 5-inch wide option. For the full-body cupid cookies, I used a 4-inch cellophane bag. However, for the cupid on heart cookies, due to it’s wider shape, I had to use a 5-inch cellophane bag. Both the 4-inch and 5-inch toppers are included in the file.

These tags and toppers are an instant download that you can print at home. Just visit his Etsy shop to purchase your copy of the downloadable file.


Filed under:

7 replies on “How to Make Cupid Cookies

  1. Just adorable as always, I missed shipping for this year but I see these on my list for next year

  2. Would you please give me the tip numbers that you use for the outlines and the eyes and smile? I think it’s a 1 or 1.5 however I would appreciate your guidance,
    Thank you very much.

    1. I use a PME #1 tip for the final outline and facial details. Thanks!

  3. I thought my cutter would NEVER come. You know how us “cookie people” are. We order it and run out to the mailbox immediately. Thanks for the tutorial!

  4. I received my cutters today. What a surprise! I love them! What font diff yuh use on the Kira cookie?

    1. It seems my keyboard had a mind of its own. What font did you use for the Kira cookie?

    2. Hi Christina, I think it was the Grenouille font.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subcribe to the Newsletter

Get promotions, new products and blog updates delivered to your inbox.