Quality Crafted Cookie Cutters & Decorating Ideas

Valentine Otter Cookies by Semi Sweet Designs

Decorated Cookies

Valentine Otter Cookies

Written by Mike Tamplin Feb 19, 2015


This post is over a week behind schedule, but better late than never. Right? I do have a good excuse though! I had a birthday this week and decided to treat myself with a little procrastination. It was lovely.

Anyways, back to the cookies. These are valentine otter cookies for your significant “otter”. Actually, you can get pretty creative with the otter puns. (i.e. “There’s no otter like you.” Or, “You otter be my Valentine.” Or, “I’m otterly in love.”) The possibilities are endless with the message you would want to get across.

And speaking of birthdays, you could easily switch out the hearts the otters are holding to presents and make them into birthday cookies. These otter cookies are pretty versatile.

Decorating Process

To make these valentine otter cookies, you can free hand the otter body design or use the template I drew up as a guide. Just print out the template and place it in your Kopykake projector, or cut out the shapes by hand and trace it onto the cookie.

You can download the otter cookie template HERE.

I used a decorative plaque cookie cutter from CopperGifts.com for these otters, but any long-shaped cutter would work fine.

Icing Instructions

  1. 1

    Begin by icing a cookie in light blue icing and allowing it to dry completely. After the icing is dry, trace out the otter body parts with a food marker. Then, fill the sections with brown icing.

    Valentine Otter cookies step 1
  2. 2

    After the brown had time to dry, start adding parts of the body. Add the ears, tummy, and one of the cheek sections. Allow those to set then add the other cheek section, feet and center heart.

    Valentine Otter cookies step 2
  3. 3

    After the new sections had time to dry, add the two arms, eyes, nose, and the bow tie ends. Allow those to set then add the center bow tie detail and the water waves around the otter.

    Valentine Otter cookies step 3

Below are the finished valentine otter cookies. The fine line details of the toes were made using a food coloring pen. I made a female version, as well. Just substitute a hair bow instead of the bow tie, add some lashes, and you got yourself a date for Mr. Otter.

Valentine Otter cookies step 4

If you’re feeling adventurous, I also included a template for a heart-shaped cookie with two otters holding hands. It’s in the file link above.

Valentine Otter Cookies by Semi Sweet Designs

I “otterly” hope you all are surviving the end of winter. I’m definitely looking forward to spring.


Filed under:

28 replies on “Valentine Otter Cookies

  1. Beautiful, as usual !!

  2. These are otter this world! So whimsical…they are some of the most fun water creatures to watch….highly entertaining! Cute, cute cookies. Happy Birthday!

    1. Thanks so much, Susie!

  3. What a sweet idea! Love the otters! So cute!

  4. in love with it… eating it will be so hard cos its beautiful

  5. I was just at the Monterey Bay Aquarium on Tuesday and the otters were so adorable, just like your cookies! I need to make some! Thanks for the tutorial, Mike!

  6. These are great! I did otter cookies once for a customer and I had to apologize because I thought they came out looking like bears floating face up lol! You nailed it!

  7. Hi Mike
    Have a question for you what edible pens do you use and where do you get them? I’m doing a craft show at south haven do you have any ideas of what cookies cutters I could do

    1. Hi Robin, I use Rainbow Dust Food pens. Here’s a link to purchase them on Amazon: http://amzn.to/1U9sEdt

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subcribe to the Newsletter

Get promotions, new products and blog updates delivered to your inbox.